Strictly Facts: A Guide to Caribbean History and Culture

*Throwback* How Caribbean Museums Built National Identity with Kevin Farmer

Alexandria Miller Episode 133

Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.

0:00 | 55:04

Send us a text message and tell us your thoughts.

Museums don’t just preserve history. They decide which stories become a nation’s memory and which stories get buried under polite silence. I’m joined by Kevin Farmer, Deputy Director of the Barbados Museum and Historical Society, to talk about Caribbean museums as real tools of nation building, cultural heritage, and post-independence identity. We start by tracing the roots of colonial museums and collections built to explain the Caribbean to Europe, often without listening to Indigenous knowledge or acknowledging the realities of slavery, resistance, and survival. From there, we move into the radical energy of the post-1960s period, when new scholars, artists, national galleries, and cultural movements helped reshape what counted as “our” history and “our” creativity across the region. 

Then we get practical about what museums still need to fix: whose voices were pushed aside, how co-curation and community collaboration can change exhibitions, and why documenting migration and labor history is urgent before firsthand accounts disappear. We also dig into decolonizing museums through provenance work and repatriation, and how technology can help connect Caribbean stories across borders and the diaspora. 

Kevin Farmer is currently Deputy Director of the Barbados Museum and Historical Society (BMHS). As Deputy Director of the Barbados Museum, he has the responsibility for museum exhibition programming and capital campaign fundraising. He holds a Master’s degree in History (Heritage Studies) from the University of the West Indies, Cave Hill, Barbados, and has lectured in Archaeology at the Department of History at the University of the West Indies, St. Augustine, Trinidad and taught at the UWI Cave Hill in their MA Heritage Studies program.  His research interests include the creation of cultural identity in post-colonial states, the role of museums in national development, the management and curation of archaeological resources, and the role of heritage in national development. 

Support the show

Connect with Strictly Facts -  Instagram | Facebook | Twitter | LinkedIn | YouTube | Website

Looking to read more about the topics covered in this episode? Subscribe to the newsletter at www.strictlyfactspod.com to get the Strictly Facts Syllabus to your email!

Want to Support Strictly Facts?

  • Rate & Leave a Review on your favorite platform
  • Share this episode with someone or online and tag us
  • Send us a DM or voice note to have your thoughts featured on an upcoming episode 
  • Donate to help us continue empowering listeners with Caribbean history and education

Produced by Breadfruit Media

Welcome And The Big Question

SPEAKER_00

Welcome to Strictly Facts, a guide to Caribbean history and culture, hosted by me, Dr. Alexandria Miller. Strictly Facts teaches the history, politics, and activism of the Caribbean and connects these themes to contemporary music and popular culture. Hello, hello, Walton people, and welcome back to another episode of Strictly Facts, a guide to Caribbean history and culture. I'm your host, Alexandria Miller, and we're kicking off this episode with an amazing discussion about nation building and national identity. We've had several conversations about protests, campaigns for Caribbean freedom, the processes by which many of our islands went through to approach independence, like the West Indian Federation. And you may have even thought about important attributes of nation building, like flags, national anthems, for instance. But along that trajectory, have you considered how important museums are in shaping new stories for our islands, once disparaged by extraction, forced labor, and of course the demeaning stories and social hierarchies created by colonial conquest? Museums, of course, have many purposes as vessels of education, for archival access and artifact holding, for public consumption, of course, the list could go on, but I think particularly for the region, museums are also a way to combat centuries of injustice as told by our history. So joining our conversation today to share the story of Caribbean museums and nation building, particularly post-the mid-20th century, and you know, to take us forward into contemporary times with the work that is being done today is Mr. Kevin Farmer, Deputy Director of the Barbados Museum and Historical Society. Mr. Farmer, thank you so much for joining me. Why don't we begin with you sharing a bit about yourself for our strictly facts audience, um your personal connection to the Caribbean, of course, and what inspired your passions for museum history and a little bit more background in your work in archaeology?

SPEAKER_01

Okay, thank you, Alessandria. It's great to be here. I know we only have a short time to discuss. So I'm a historian and historical archaeologist by training, born in Barbados, um, but I consider myself to be a West Indian or Caribbean person. Um, educated at the University of the West Indies at Cape Hill and at Mona and back to Cape Hill. I've taught at St. Augustine in Trinidad. So I've traveled the three main campuses of the UWI and um worked in Trinidad and traveled all over the region. And for me, museums are really our storytellers. It's where our tangible and tangible memories are held, and it's that space that allows us almost a free reign into discussing who we are: the good, the bad, the ugly. It's a space where marginalized voices get to be heard. Um, whether there are poor white community of Barbados, um, East Indian communities in Barbados, um, as well as diving into and exploring the nuances of enslavement. For me, that's the importance of museums. Um, being the space where multiple stories can be told at any time or told together. And it's where the the collective memory of a nation resides and where the importance of not only continuing the memory but learning from the past as well becomes really, very important in in a way, expressing who we are as a people and understanding why we do certain things or why certain things might have happened in the past, so that hopefully we don't repeat it. Um, so in a way, we are the physical manifestation of Sankofa. We look back in order that we can chart our way forward.

SPEAKER_00

Indeed, to go back and fetch it, as they would say, right?

SPEAKER_01

Yes, to go back and fetch it. And and I would say that my interest in history started at a very young age. Um, from my my mom taking me to the public library here at home, and she reminded me that the first book I ever borrowed was a history book, which is kind of funny. I was about maybe five or six. So I've always been fascinated by the past, but about what it can tell us about our future and our present. And I guess the family history, now that I think about it, drove me in that direction. So on my father's side, his father was born in Panama of Barbadian parents who went to build the canal. And I just found that to be utterly fascinating. And they sent their children back to be raised in Barbados. Um, so I guess that early connection, understanding migration and how it affects families and the history behind why you are where you are, um, kind of fascinated me as a young child. And that fascination just kind of kept hold uh during secondary school and then choosing history as a first degree. Um archaeology came about because those were the courses offered, and it made me recognize that a simple object could have as many stories as a book, and and the multiple stories that can be told about a simple object is what in fact drew me to that discipline. And of course, all of that culminates in almost the open experience that is a museum. There's text, there are objects, there's sound, there's moving image, and and there's the space in which to tell these stories and the time to really dive into them and try to understand them, and then to see how people get fascinated by learning these uh new facts. But first, one of the hardest things to do in a museum is write text. 250 words to try to get over all of this in-depth information. It really taught you how to be succinct, um, and in a way, how to in a way tease the audience to learn more. In my early career, I found that really, really fascinating. And I still do.

SPEAKER_00

Thank you so much for sharing just a bit about who you are and all that is involved, I think, really in museum building that you know those on maybe our side, my side, um, might not even think of. So really appreciate you sharing a bit about that. I definitely want to kick off our discussion today with taking us a little bit even before getting to, you know, these post-independence created museums, um, and really chart what was some of the you know impetus for colonially established museums, if there's a way of putting it, um, what purpose they served at the time before, you know, many of our islands became independent and the goals of those curators, um, many of those who were, you know, obviously coming from UK, from France, Netherlands, the list could go on, right? Um, just to really establish a reference point for what happens um later on as we'll continue on in our conversation.

SPEAKER_01

No problem. So I'll I'll start that first with a shameless plug. Uh so a couple of years ago, I was quite privileged. Um my director at the museum, Alessandra Cummings, is very well known in the museum world, not only in the region, but outside of it. Um we got together with another colleague, um, Rosalind Russell from Australia, and came up with the idea for a Caribbean museums book. Because so often when you're looking for research on Caribbean museums, it's not written by people in the Caribbean. Or we might be asked to write a small um article in a large anthology uh made up of persons from around the world in museology, but it was never one that was specifically focused on the Caribbean. Um so we brainstormed and recognized that we need to tell the full story of the development of museums in this region. And the title for me was most app, From Plantation to Nation, because it's coming out of that enlightenment era of trying to order the world around it. Um, that we get into categorization by by Linnaeus, who people remember for his classification of people into racial hierarchies. But before that, he was really the one who came up with how do we categorize the world that we see? What's the taxonomy in the nomenclature? And he did all of that work. And so from very early on, we can almost start to say that as persons encountered this new world, they began to collect and try to, in their limited way, bring some order to it. Um, of course, telling their particular story. So very much very early on, those colonial collections were really about telling the story of the space that they found through their particular lens, not necessarily listening or even fully understanding um what the indigenous knowledge was. So I guess the classic example for me would be the core collection that started the British Museum has its origins in the Caribbean. So Sahan Sloan collection, which was purchased by the British Parliament, that went on to be the British Museum's founding collection, a lot of that collection was based on what he um found, kept, took up, borrowed, stole, maybe in some instances, um, of the space that he'd now come into as a young physician, whether in Jamaica or Barbados, or his travels, because he was in the in the retinue of the governor at the time. And that formed his understanding of this new world that he was finding. And it's about understanding that new world, almost in juxtaposition to the world you already knew, is really the nucleus of what early museums or early cabinets of curiosities would have been in this region. Uh, so we go back to the development of the Institute of Jamaica and what was called the Victorian Institute in the 19th century. Um, those are really the first uh early museums set up as museums in the English-speaking Caribbean at the time. But the outlook was colonial in that how do we better understand the space that we're in relative to where we've come from? So the collections and the stories always covered the indigenous or are the enslaved or the indentured. It was never our story. Um, so even the setup of the museum where I work at the Barbados Museum, created in 1933, is very much as a colonial museum. It's really how the elite saw themselves and saw the history of the island around them in juxtaposition to the UK, to the mother country. And one great example of this, we when you look through some of the early documents at the museum, um they outlined, oh, we want to look at archaeology and understand the native past, we want to understand architecture and how we, I mean, we meaning Europeans got here and the ability to trace that. But one of the early founding members said, but we don't want to talk about enslavement. We we don't want to remind um the local population of where they came from, because that might incite them to rebellion. And it's only when you dive into the history and you recognize that a lot of our history as enslaved people is very much foundationally about our resistance to that enslavement. You know, understand why that was said. Because how do you want to control a people and then still acknowledge the fact that, well, they fought against this control from the get-go. But in the post-colonial where we are now, it's important to tell those stories because we need to understand that we are the descendants of persons who resisted. We are descendants of those who survive. We are not victims, and that's an extremely important narrative to tell coming out of the independence movement of the 60s, recognizing that there's still some English-speaking islands that are still not independent. They're still colonies of the United Kingdom, even though they'll try to find some really fancy, wonderful word to dress it up, um, like the French do in saying Department de Autonomia. Yeah, still a colony. You still don't have control over your own internal or foreign policy. You don't. So museums become the spaces that get to tell those stories, but we got to recognize where we came from. We came in the most part from an institution that sought to say, um, well, yes, you're a colony, and this is how you should behave, um, relative to the mother country, as opposed to really telling the truth about who we are and how we got here and the nuances that developed. Um, and I think that's our responsibility today is to not only speak truth to power, but to uncover that truth wherever it is and to give voice to it. And over the last decade at the museum, um, we've gotten into looking at how we can have greater collaboration with the community in terms of how do we bring these exhibits or public programming together. So, anywhere from what initially I discussed in Plantation Nation to Old Talk, or what a colleague of mine, Natalie McGuire Batson, has just developed in terms of community engagement. I've now forgot what her term is. I'll come back to me during during the course of this discussion. Um but she has uh she's formulated uh a really good foundation of what that could be, and allowing our museums to speak to multivocality as well, because we live in a region where we're all mixed. Um, persons are white, persons are black, persons are in-between, and Indian and Chinese, and African and Javanese, depending on where you go, and indigenous, depending on where you go in the region. So that our museums then need to be reflective of those histories and those stories. And I think that's critically important, especially when we look at the world that we're in, that people are divided along not only ethnic but religious lines. How do we combat that in the space in which we live? How do we give voice to it? I think that's critically important. And how do we tell some of those untold stories? Um, so that's part of the ongoing research. And recognizing that the curator is not as he or she was seen 50 years ago as the person who's controlling the door at the entrance. You know, you're not the gatekeeper, you're simply the facilitator and the guardian to ensure that these stories are passed on from generation to generation. And I think that's how Caribbean museums and galleries are evolving.

SPEAKER_00

I think that was beautifully said and even takes me to my next question, right? We have obviously, as you pointed, a set of museums that were founded prior to our nationalist movements and how they've evolved. But really, in your scope, how have you seen those that you know came up post-independence highlight reshaping our national identity? I know places like National Gallery of Jamaica was the first art gallery, National Art Gallery of the Anglophone Caribbean being founded in I think 1974. Um, but really, what was the scope of those museums coming to be and what ideas did they have in mind, especially as the nations are forming, um, especially as, you know, their new ways of us talking? There is also at the time, you know, scholars really having either been educated abroad in, you know, the quote unquote former mother country, depending on, you know, the years here, but coming back and really wanting to be like, okay, this is the history of Jamaica or Barbados as told through our eyes. How did those two dynamics really work together to shape the future of museums post-colonially?

SPEAKER_01

Um, when we take a look at those post-independent um museums, galleries, heritage sites in the post-independence period, and it's a radical rethink of who we are. And part of it is really about those new academics who are I were being trained at University College of the West Indies, which is established in 48, first at Mona, and how they in turn respond to the creation of this young nation. We've moved through Federation, purposes have lamented oh, there it didn't work out in 62. But there's this agitation. We need to be independent. Look at what's happened in India, look at what's happening in Africa. Um, some of these potential leaders went to school with those persons who were leading those nationalist movements in those um spaces, whether it's Africa or the subcontinent. And the history was changing. So the social history that is being taught and being researched in the late 60s and 70s, um that privileges us um built on on the on Williams' thesis of capitalism and slavery, Walter Rodney's how you're underdeveloped Africa, um, Elsa Kavaya, um Woodwill Marshall, Sidney Mint. All of that is is building up to the point where who are we? What are we? What have we done? How do we showcase this? How do we channel all of this energy into this into this independent movement? So you've got the development of the National Art Gallery in in Jamaica, but I will say alongside that for Jamaica that I find most interesting is the development of what was a craft museum in in Spanish Tongue at the same time, which really to me said we're privileging our ability to innovate at uh at a local level. And so craft is not just craft, craft is about how we have found solutions to local problems in a given space. And so the two of them together, so art at one end, which is seen up there, and and craft, which is seen down there, and they both have their independent spaces to tell the story of Jamaica. Um, and of course, the development of the Adamani school, um, that also said academics are great, but there must be equal footing for the artists. Whether the person is a visual artist or dancer or singer or poet or playwright, they must be equal footing. And the 70s then becomes pivotal for a whole number of reasons. The black power movement, the the acknowledgement, even though we haven't fully acknowledged it, how black Mycenaean students and Black Mycenaean intellectuals are in fact foundational to the civil rights movement in the states in the 60s and 70s. Um we don't pay enough attention to that. And all of them coming together in the region to begin. To have the question about who we are and recognize that 74 period, we're getting into the first CARI Festa, which is about us celebrating us. So here we are, these regional governments coming together. And for the audience who don't remember CARIFESTA or Karifta and may only see Karifta as an athletics competition, uh, Karifta is really the precursor to CARICOM, or should we say it is the stepchild of federation, um, where there's a recognition that there is some good to be had by bringing us together in a regional market system economically. But then person said, well, economics is one thing, but what about the social and cultural? And that breeds car fasta. And and for that almost decade, there's a series of policy workshops and meetings and gatherings about how do we advance our respective cultures. So Kamal Braffit writes uh what is almost the pillar of what our cultural policy is in the 70s. The same thing happens in Jamaica and it happens in Trinidad, and these are still our guiding documents to today, coming out of that radical phase. We're still in that radical phase because we we continue to evolve and refine those policy documents and bring them to life. Um, in some cases, um what happens on the street overtakes the policy. We just have to look at the the growth and development of ska and mento into reggae and and the independent producers and and singers. There's there's an early Barbadian singer, but he's one of the early reggae singers in Jamaica. In fact, Bob Marley and the Wailers were his backup at one point. And and there's a there's there's a wonderful story where Bob mentions him. The name will come back to me at some time. Um and we need to tell the stories because even though we see music as national, music at that time was very Caribbean. Musicians moved wherever there was work, didn't stay static. Um, and and that needs also to be acknowledged and recognized. But all of this is coalescing, and part of the manifestation of that is actually the development of some of those early institutions. So Jackie Opal was the was the singer in Barbados who made it big in Jamaica, um, singing ska and reggae, and then moved back to Barbados to invent a new music called Spooch, but he died quite young. But but pivotal in the development of reggae and bringing to light um Tosh and Marley and the Whalers. So we also need to understand the interconnectedness of our stories as well. But here you have for the first time, 74 as a precursor to Carfasta, um, where you actually get to see your own art and not just your own art utilizing the European canon, but your own intuitive artists presenting what they see of themselves to you. So you almost have that reflective mirror. Here's how we see ourselves. Let's let's really have a talk about this, and that goes on to spawn a whole set of um national galleries throughout the region, or the creation of national collections, sands, galleries. And at the same time, you'll find that most of the postcard institutions, oddly enough, are galleries. They're not necessarily museums, they're they're all about the visual. That might have been a deliberate policy. We we got to go back and really take a critical look at what those policy documents um were saying. Um, but it's about acknowledging that we can create and that we can innovate. And I still think that we are somewhat in that particular sphere as well, where we are recognizing and acknowledging that we are creators and not just consumers. And and and the interesting thing for me to note is that National Gallery Jamaica in 74 happens after the first CARI Festa, which is 1972 in Guyana. So, you know, what is the what is the impetus um from CARI Festa that leads to the development of national galleries um in the 1970s and early 80s in the region. Um, but it's about recognizing, for me, it's about recognizing that we are creative and acknowledging that. And then, of course, at the end of the day, the artist is always the original critique of their society, uh, whether in music, dance, song, or or moving visuals. So, yeah.

Who Got Left Out

SPEAKER_00

That brings me to a point you made earlier, um, really thinking about the diversity of the region, right? You know, in terms of art identity and national makeup or ethnic makeup, right, and racial makeup. We have people of Asian descent, people of African descent, et cetera, et cetera. Um, I've, you know, we've had episodes on Jewish identity in the Caribbean and um all of that to say our national movements were really, in a sense, to uphold our black populations, right? Ones that um were plagued by centuries of enslavement and wanting to reshape the memory of what was, you know, determined by the colonial bodies. How successful do you think these museums springing up post the 60s, how successful were they in doing that? And then, you know, as an add-on, what were maybe some of the challenges or what has evolved since then to also uphold the legacies of, you know, say indeed indentured servitude or, you know, many of the other um ethnic bodies we have?

Co-Curation And Community Collaboration

SPEAKER_01

Yeah. Um, critically, we were they weren't very good at telling the story of everyone um simply because they were so focused on dealing with the binary. How do you deal with telling the story of an island or country that has come out of this colonial oppression? And and the major colonial oppression was about enslavement and and being a colony. How do you position your people, the majority of whom are of African descent for the most part, in building them up and making them realize that they could achieve everything? So that early post-independent development of uh museums and art galleries and heritage institutions was very much about confronting that colonial past and in some doing, pushing um smaller groups, um marginalized in terms of I'm dealing with size, not necessarily economic clout, um, to the periphery. And it's only in the last 20 years, 30 years, because you've got now remember, we're in 2024. Wow, which is amazing for some of us. So 24 years ago, it was 2000, 10 years before that, we're we're at 1990. So in the last 34 years, because we have in a way successfully planted what it is to be uh an independent nation state, um, that we can begin to say, okay, what are the other stories that we've not been telling? And in fact, when you look in those spaces, the mere fact that you've got museums or galleries dedicated to um the Jewish past, Asian, and Asian meaning South Asian as well, so indentured andor China andor Java also says um that that initial movement failed them. And we've got to acknowledge that. Um even even in terms of how those national museums told the story of women, in most cases they didn't. They told the stories of elite women for the most part, but not of everyday women. Um, so part of the redress, I'll say, in the last 20 years is about bringing the marginal voices from the periphery to the core and giving them the space. And I think we're right now in that particular period. Um, so uh at the Barbados Museum, if you were to go to um our website, we we speak to some of how we've engaged with those communities. We're in the middle, midst of doing an online digital exhibition on East Indian migration to Barbados, which didn't happen during the period of indentureship. Um, in fact, it's a early 1910, 1920 migration directly from India to Barbados, persons looking for economic opportunity, but not indentured. Um, so it's it's different than what happens in Jamaica, Guyana, Trinidad, Suriname, for instance. But we recognize that there's a need to tell that story. Um, and just recently I did a program where I spoke about the poor white community in Barbados, which we refer to as um red legs. Um I can't remember what the Jamaican term is. Um in the French Islands, it is petit biket, small white. Um, but we need to recognize and give voice to those communities because they're still here with us. Uh, and to understand how they see themselves in relation to the nation state is is extremely important. And and then, of course, how do we deal with women? One, how do we deal with ever marginalized groups, um, whether they are hearing or sighting paired? How do we allow our exhibitions to be accessible to them? So these are still some of the things that we're we're grappling with now. But I think we've we've come a long way, but there's so much fervor that we need to go um to give voice. Um, I remember a couple of years ago going to National Museums Jamaica, the Social History Museum, and they had a really fantastic exhibition on um the early development of SCA and Mento, something that you might not have seen 30 years before. Um, so there's a reason um to then dive into sub-genres and subcultures um to understand and bring them out to the fore and allow those stories to be told. Um, I think that is where we need to go. So now the intersection between film and how film and documentaries can help museums reach new audiences and tell those stories becomes an important tool in how we develop our interaction and activity and programming and accessibility uh becomes critically, critically important. And the other aspect in there is, and we're still trying to figure this out, how best do we engage the community to find out what they really want to see at a museum? We've got to do that as well. You can never make the assumption that we know best, we do not. So that's why co-curation is is so fundamental as a tool of engagement where the communities become co-curators with you in whatever you're doing.

SPEAKER_00

As you were talking, I also thought of Trinidad's um Indian Caribbean museum sprang up during 2006. So, you know, very much in line with this.

SPEAKER_01

Very much in line. Yeah, very much in line. Um, and and then of course, there are those things that happened in this century that we've not even delved into properly. There's no trade union museum per se.

SPEAKER_00

Right.

SPEAKER_01

Um, there isn't a museum of migration. So we better understand what migration to Cuba, Panama, Colombia, internal, well, when I say internal, internal carbine migration. Um, Barbanians to Trinidad in the 1890s and the early part of the 20th century. Uh, migrations to Jamaica following United Food Company around the turn of the century, how does that alter populations as well? So there's so much more to be told, and there's so many different stories that we have yet to explore, is that we've got to start the work now. Um, because unfortunately, we've we're missing out on almost the firsthand accounts of the people who were directly involved in that. Um, it almost makes me think that as a region, we we need to have a wider program similar to what happened in the States after the depression, where um was it working, was it working People's Association went into different spaces and simply recording the lived experience of people, um, recognizing that it was important enough to record it. Maybe they didn't quite know what to do with it. When the mere fact that you archived that material meant that 20, 30, 40 years later, someone can go back to it and have an understanding of what all of that meant and write books, have documentaries, create exhibits. We need to be doing that now. Um, in in terms of labor movements, migration, um, the progress of women, how do we deal with marginalized groups? We need to capture that information now. Also, it's going to be lost to us. And I think that's that's one of the key things that museums can do. Um, recognizing, of course, then it means that as one of the institutions, we need we need to be placed firmly within the developmental agenda of our governments, which for the most part only remembers culture once or twice a year, whether it's carnival or some larger national event, um, that they then decide, oh dear, yes, we need a cultural component. Cultural component has always been here. Um, you just, you know, need to pay a bit more attention to it. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00

I couldn't have you on this episode without talking about, you know, more recent conversations uh around museums. I think this more so um has contended with museums in the quote unquote developed world, right? So I I particularly think of that scene in Black Panther in the first movie, um, you know, when the curator is like, oh, this is from da-da-da-da-da, you know. Um, and then, you know, rightfully so, um, she gets clapped backed on in a sense and is like, actually, this artifact that, you know, you've held in your museum for however long was stolen, right? And so I that's something that I necessarily haven't thought about in terms of um what artifacts and things that we hold, or you know, if there have been attempts to get artifacts back from the UK, from France, um, and even just how things have been, you know, moved or repatriated back for our region.

Missing Museums For Labor And Migration

SPEAKER_01

We're slowly in that beginning process of repatriation, but there's a step before that. We we actually have to have the engagement where we understand, well, what's in your collection that speaks about us? In some instances, um, a lot of the museums um in in the former metropoles don't know what they have. Um I've been part of a group recently, or invited on to a group recently, um, museums in Scotland who are trying to understand what's in their collection in the Caribbean and Africa. Because in some instances, their curators aren't trained in those areas, so they don't know, or they haven't really done the deep dive into their catalogs to understand the provenance of what they have, and then beginning to have conversations with us in the region, not only about what the object is, um, but what does it say? And then the the larger conversation about okay, great, you have it, we don't. How do we look at repatriation? What does that look like? Um, and it might be an easier discussion in Scotland who have begun to repatriate over the last almost two decades material, as opposed to in England, where they're so resistant. Because, of course, if they started to go down one line, we all know that the Greeks will remind them the elgin marbles don't belong to you. There's spoils of war, there's there's a need for some you know reversal and reciprocity. Yes. Um, but we're getting there. So I know later on this year there's going to be a repatriation of a natural history object from Scotland to Jamaica, which is going to be amazing. So I look forward to when they they release that information. I just mentioned it here um to pique interest and to tease. Um, but Shani Roper at UWI Muna, who's a curator there, is the person to talk to about that. But repatriation is beginning. Those conversations are happening, perhaps not as fast as we would like. Um, but but they're happening. And even in the areas of archaeology, we begin to have discussions about well, what does archaeology look like when we've got outside researchers coming in? Um, there's need to talk about a decolonization around that as well, because all of our institutions, for the most part, and our disciplines, um, especially archaeology, are created out of colonial context. And in fact, created because of colonization. Um, how do how do they at the foundational level begin to redress how they were created for the future? How do they address the imbalances and what does decolonization look like? Um, not only global north to global south, uh, but global south to global south. And there are going to be some difficult discussions, but necessary discussions, which we have to have if we want to be honest in the telling of that story. Um yeah, and I think that's where we're going. We we also recognize that there's been pushback, whether it's being termed as being anti-woke, whatever that is. Um but for me, it's about the telling of the truth. It's about no longer hiding historical facts, but being open and transparent about them and seeing how they can lead to healing on the one side, closing of trauma at the other, but it's necessary.

SPEAKER_00

That brings me to, you know, one of my favorite questions of all, as our listeners will know, I ask this question every episode. Um, I think, and as you rightly pointed to, in terms of our music, um, our festivals, carnival, et cetera, there is a way that our popular culture holds our history that, you know, people might not always put the two and two together. And so my aim through this question is always to weed that out a little bit and, you know, maybe get our listeners to read a novel or, you know, listen to a song that references a particular moment in our history. So is there something like that for you that is really reflective of museums and national identity coming up during this period that is highlighted in popular culture?

Repatriation And Decolonizing Collections

SPEAKER_01

Oh wow. Uh yes. And what I'm going to bring to mind will reference both. Jamaica, but it has resonance. So we have a small African gallery here at the museum that we created about a decade ago. It was a temporary exhibition that stood up for 17 years because people were so interested. And then around 2000, we said, okay, we need to make this a permanent gallery. And so we expanded the gallery from 200 square feet to 800 square feet and sought to tell in very broad breath strokes about the history of the continent going back from the development of early hominids into Homo sapiens all the way up to what Africa looks today. And there is one exhibition when we take people through, we remind them of Bob Marley's song War. Because it's an Ethiopian scroll. So and we we use that to show how global events continue to shape us and how we in turn continue to shape the world around us. And to remind people that though we might see ourselves as small, our impact on the world is so much greater than that. And this is for me a very important message that anyone coming through a museum in the region should leave knowing our impact on the wider world. I think it's Zimbabwe. And we we have Marley Song Zimbabwe and reminding people of the invitation at the time, you know, so to recognize connections but also recognize resonance. Um for me. The other more important object I'll point to in our museum is we have a small agate bead excavated from the enslaved barrel ground at Newton, which is a plantation here. Now, this agate bead, I remind people, is globalization. It's an agate bead that comes from India, made its way across the Atlantic, was buried in the coffin of an enslaved man who was brought to an island in the Mid-Atlantic to grow an Asian grass called sugar cane for process and export to Europe. And this is the 18th century. So globalization starts here. Understand why we are where we are and the outsize role that we have played in the world and will continue to play, um, to ground us as to who we are and to recognize that our story doesn't begin and end with enslavement, but is a much larger story as well, as a people.

Marley, Sankofa, And A Single Bead

SPEAKER_00

I will definitely add those to our strictly fact syllabus, as well as your co-edited book From Plantation to Nation, which I think walks us through beautifully some of, you know, not only the history of those founding museums during our colonial period, but also the history of museums like the National Gallery in Jamaica, like the Junkanoo Museum in Bahamas, that are really, you know, doing the work that we've been talking about today, showcasing the histories of not just, you know, those who were colonized, but also those smaller subset groups who have, you know, didn't necessarily get the early recognition in our immediate post-colonial period. So definitely wanted to highlight that as well. And I'll add it to our Sterly Fact Syllabus and in the show notes. Um, and so for my final question for our conversation today, we've talked about some of the ways that museums have been evolving, some of the work that needs to be done. We are now in a period where several islands have even, you know, moved to republic status, or as you very well know, of course, right? Um, or, you know, have been talking about moving to republic status as well. How do you think museums will reflect the last 50-ish, you know, depending on which island, of course, but the last few decades of us being independent for the future and, you know, just what ways you see them either shaping the future, um, using things like technology to connect across even the region and the diaspora?

Republic Movements And Tech Futures

SPEAKER_01

Um let me take it first, starting with the movement towards Republican status. Uh, for me, the movement towards Republican status is the continuation of a continuum. Um, from the time we were brought, forcibly brought here, we resisted. The various ways in which we have resisted and manifested that resistance lies both in physical rebellion, moves through to the establishment of trade unions, the want to have workers' and people's rights to the independence movement in the 1960s, um, through to republicanism. So for me, it's a continuum, it's the last four or five hundred years continuum towards self-government and self-rule. But in that, recognizing that we're not the only people in this space, but how do we bring along our indigenous communities in the spaces in which they're still found? How do we bring along our marginalized communities in the spaces where they are? And utilizing technology not only to capture memory, but utilizing technology to create content that allows us to tell the interconnectedness of those stories across our entire region. Um, our carbine sea is not a block. Our carbine sea is conduit to each other. And the various stories that we've told over time, the fact that a national hero of Barbados is born in Trinidad, with Barbadian parents, you know, the fact that one of the major um labor leaders in Trinidad comes from a smaller island called Grenada, we need to tell the interconnectedness of those stories. So technology allows us to capture, but also then allows us to build up content. Um, I look forward to the day where we ourselves together create uh a documentary called the Caribbean and not have to watch one on the BBC that really doesn't reflect us. Like, likewise, with podcasts like yours, we we go to that online portal and download those multiple stories about us. I think that's where technology is pushing us, and I think that's where we need where we need to go. Um so podcasts like yours and others being the Coursera or or the West Indiana of who we are becomes necessary going forward. And it's in the small and and in the big things. Um whether it's about the complexities of the rums that we we create and drink, or it's about how we take that basic product called cornmeal and turn it into so many different things, whether it's um dukunna or peme or conki or kinke, turn cornmeal or cuckoo or polento, you know, it's it's about creating that and having access to it and understanding the connectedness between them, I think is where we're going. And technology will will and should allow us to do that. It should make our stories accessible and our shared paths accessible as well. And I think that's where museums need to go. We need to see ourselves as content creators across multiple platforms, utilizing all media. That is that is what we are. In fact, that that makes us stand out in terms of the heritage sphere in the region. We are content creators uh because we house both two-dimensional and three-dimensional, tangible and intangible objects of our past that can speak to a future. Um, and I think that's where our strength lies. And it's how we need to build on and build out the telling of our story.

Final Reflections And Close

SPEAKER_00

I have no final words after that. I think that was effectively said. Um, thank you for the work that you're doing for all of the museum curators, you know, really helping to shape not only the education and awareness that we have for the region, um, the movements that we've made across the world, really and our impact on the world. Um, and really just, you know, changing the landscape of how we define ourselves away from, you know, what was colonially imposed. So thank you so much, Mr. Farmer, of course, for joining me for this episode to our Strictly Facts family. I hope you enjoyed learning a bit about museums, the history of them, and how they're moving forward. And I will, of course, add all of the, you know, many things we talked about, whether it's the resources, the books, the songs, um, and links, of course, to the Barbados Museum and Historical Society, to our um syllabus and show notes for you all to check out yourselves. So again, thank you so much for listening. Thank you, Mr. Farmer and Lickle Moore, everyone.

SPEAKER_01

Yeah, thank you very much. I enjoyed it.

Podcasts we love

Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.

The Style & Vibes Podcast Artwork

The Style & Vibes Podcast

Mikelah Rose | Style & Vibes
Reels & Riddims Artwork

Reels & Riddims

Kerry-Ann & Mikelah